Marion County Indiana judge rules 1st and 4th Amendments meaningless.


An article at The Indy Star from 2 March 2011.

A Marion County judge has ruled, for the first time in Indiana, that news media outlets can be ordered by the court to reveal identifying information about posters to their online forums.

In rulings this week and last week, Marion Superior Court Judge S.K. Reid became the first judge in Indiana to rule on whether the state journalism shield law protects media outlets from being forced to disclose names of anonymous posters on their websites or other identifying information about those posters, said Kevin Betz, an attorney for Jeffrey Miller, former chief executive of Junior Achievement of Central Indiana.

The rulings came in a defamation lawsuit Miller filed last year. He is seeking to broaden the list of defendants in his case to include people who criticized him anonymously last year on websites run by The Indianapolis Star, Indianapolis Business Journal and WRTV (Channel 6). The case is among a growing number of defamation claims nationally that target anonymous Internet posters to websites operated by news media and other owners.

One immediately wonders on which sides of the political aisles reside the plaintiffs, defendants and of course, the leanings of Judge Reid.

‘Cyberbullying’ isn’t what this case is about. Not hardly. It’s about shutting down dissent.

Let’s put it this way: Nice ‘nudge’, judge.

By choice, many Americans are not anonymous on the internet. I am one of those people. I say what I mean, mean what I say, plus understand the consequences.

However, many others are anonymous, wish to remain that way and as American Citizens, all of us – anonymous and not – are protected by The First and Fourth Amendments To The Constitution Of The United States Of America.

Judge S.K. Reid of The Marion County Indiana Court has unilaterally disengaged the laws of the land and ignored her own state protections of it’s citizens.

By the way, The Indy Star and WRTV have steadfastly refused to provide any information on internet posters. However, The Indiana Business Journal did provide personal data of their website readers and commenters.

Kenny Solomon
South Florida

Cross-posted at Israel Survival Updates and at The American Survival Guide.

Follow Israel Survival Updates On Twitter.

0 0 vote
Article Rating
Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
March 7, 2011 10:45 am

Judge Scherry Reid

March 7, 2011 11:08 am

This may be where the rubber meets the road. Regardless of partisanship, if the Press community does not, with the aid of all their allies at ACLU, et cetera, rise up to have this stricken down, the die will be cast and the jig will be up as far as their being in collusion with the forces of tyranny.

March 7, 2011 1:18 pm

In this same vein, I read somewhere a few weeks ago about the government touting something called a “trusted Internet address” or some such. Why, yes! What a great way to tidy up all those pesky ‘verification’ details and allow us ‘concerned citizens’ to sleep more soundly at night (up until, of course, that knock upon the door).

March 7, 2011 2:29 pm

I love the way Kenny, you can ferret out these nice little tidbits which are taking us closer to totalitarian government.

And yes, as you keep reminding us, it can happen here, and it is happening here.

Brian Hibbert
March 7, 2011 5:27 pm

Oh my! I post regularly on my local paper’s board. And I use the mysterious pseudonym on BrianHibbert. I wonder what will happen if they find out who I am?